Water heater planning

Tank vs. tankless: what changes?

There is no universal winner. The right comparison includes household demand, fuel, space and the work needed to install the system.

The short answer

A storage heater keeps a tank of heated water. A tankless heater heats water as it flows through. Different sizing methods and installation needs mean that swapping one for the other is not simply a gallon-for-gallon choice.

Compare the whole installation

Planning questions, not a product recommendation
QuestionStorage tankTankless
DemandDiscuss stored capacity and recovery with the installer.Discuss simultaneous demand and required temperature rise.
FitCheck dimensions, access and existing connections.Check mounting space, fuel supply and venting requirements for the chosen model.
CostCompare installation and operating costs.Include any changes the conversion requires, not just the heater price.

Questions for the installer

Do not alter gas, electrical or venting connections yourself. This guide is for planning, not installation instructions.

Source and review

Based on the U.S. Department of Energy Building America Strategy Guideline: Water Heater Selection. No local installer has reviewed this draft yet. No savings, price, rebate or suitability promise is made.

Next: prepare for an installation quote

Planning a water heater installation?

Start with the unit you have and the installation you need.